Thursday, June 28, 2012

Consumer Products Safety Commission Lead Study

Lead has been mentioned by some critics as a risk associated with turf fields.  Some folks are pointing to a YouTube video of a 2008 ABC news story in support of this claim.  Importantly, the 2008 ABC new report references a pending U.S Consumer Products Safety Commission Study, but unfortunately the short piece on YouTube does not discuss the actual results of that study.

Those results can be found here.  Specifically, the CPSC concluded that "young children are not at risk from exposure to lead in these fields."

Also, as mentioned during the presentation to the Commissioners on June 25, the turf companies that have submitted bids for Middle/Wildcat all use lead free products.

Middle/Wildcat Turf Proposal

The field plan presented to the Commissioners on June 25 can be found here.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Turf in Other Communities

This link provides some interesting information compiled and presented by a community (Arlington, VA) that faced many of the same issues as Mt. Lebanon when deciding whether or not to turf their fields.  They now have 12!  I don't think we need 12, but this report more or less confirms what many of us having been saying about adding just 1.

Also, this is a great collection of articles concerning the many communities right here in Western PA that have recently made the move to turf:


Upper St. Clair - Recent Turf and Lighting Project Completed at Boyce Middle School



Peters Township

1.  Pleasant Valley Elementary Turf and Lighting Project - ...The project includes a turfed soccer/lacrosse/football field, restroom facilities, additional parking, a basic sound system, basic concession stands, lighting, bleachers and improved access to the field and Pleasant Valley parking lots...Golembiewski said the athletic field project is not so much a priority as it is a necessity and a fair decision.  “Every board member here should be commended to have the courage to make a tough decision, because this is a tough decision,” she said. “This will be the need of many of our kids. It is the worst time to spend money, but it is the best time to spend money if you look at the interest rates.”





2.  Peterswood Park Turf and Lighting Project - Peters council has voted to spend $895,430 to install artificial turf on a soccer field at Peterswood Park



Bethel Park - Fundraising to Turf Over Park Avenue Community Field - "The goal is to raise money to install, with the municipality, synthetic turf at the Park Avenue field..."



Fox Chapel - Recently Completed All Turf Baseball Field...The baseball diamond is just one part of a three-pronged renovation project to on-campus athletic facilities. O’Brien calls it “phase 1.”  “Phase 2” is an all-turf, 90-yard practice field for football, lacrosse, soccer and other sports. “Phase 3” is an updated softball field, which also will have a turf infield. Ground has yet to be broken for the second and third projects.  “Someone will always have a turf field to play on or practice on now,” O’Brien said.



North Park - Allegheny County paid $836,000 from its capital budget for the improvements at Lt. J.C. Stone Field in North Park...The North Park football field is a popular location, she said. As a result of heavy use in previous years by high school, middle school and other teams, the natural grass field was "turning into a mud pit," she said. The new surface will hold up better, allow for more games and reduce maintenance costs, she said.


South Park - 2005 - Non-profit entity built soccer field turf facility on land leased from Jefferson Memorial Park.  This complex is the first turf facility in the South Hills not affiliated with a school district.



Recent High School Stadium Turf Projects:

North Allegheny - 2008 - The North Allegheny school board approved an $860,000 bid Wednesday from Sports Construction Group of Cleveland to replace the artificial turf and fix the surrounding track at Newman Stadium.


Gateway - 2012 - Turf replacement set to begin at Antimarino Stadium


Penn Hills - 2012 - Penn Hills will use a $200,000 grant from the Steelers...to install synthetic turf, new bleachers and a scoreboard.


Turf Petition

I started a petition on a whim this morning to see how much community support there is for the Middle/Wildcat proposal.  In less than a day and with only minimal outreach, the online petition now has 75 signatures. 

Please consider signing the petition now . . . and tell your friends and neighbors to do the same.  Thanks!

Friday, June 22, 2012

Field Proposal To Be Presented on June 25

The Mt. Lebanon Commissioners previously requested that the youth sports groups develop a proposal/plan for adding synthetic turf to one of our existing field spaces.  Since that time, members of the youth sports groups have met with representatives from various turf companies, lighting companies, field space consultants, the municipal staff and the Commissioners.  The plan will be presented on Monday June 25 @ 6:15PM during the Commission Discussion Session in the Commission Chambers.  Please come and listen to this exciting proposal.

Friday, June 15, 2012

BP's focus on fields

This timely article appeared in the recent issue of The Almanac.  Please continue to let your Commissioner know that you support a turf project in Mt. Lebanon so that we can similarly maximize the recreational opportunities for our residents.  You can email all of the Commissioners at commission@mtlebanon.org. 

I've also copied the entire article here:


BP's focus on fields

By Susan Schmeichel For The Almanac writer@thealmanac.net


With the new high school building completed and opened, Bethel Park School Board is now focusing on completing the rest of the project.

The former campus has been demolished and plans call for the remaining site to be developed into a 378-space parking lot, eight tennis courts, three full-sized sports practice fields, a softball field and a new freshman baseball field.

Board members recently approved lighting for both of the upper level multi-purpose fields from Musco Lighting at a cost not to exceed $195,000, as well as a change order to have Clista Electric install the lights at a cost not to go over $116,468.

In addition, board members approved seeking bids for a concession stand facility, synthetic field scoreboard and a softball batting cage at a cost not to exceed $263,532.
Board members also approved a change order to replace the sod in the upper field with a synthetic surface at a cost not to go above $425,000. 

High school baseball coach Tony Fisher said the new fields will be a big improvement over the old campus sports facilities.

"The synthetic turf fields will allow ample opportunities for the high school baseball and softball teams to have practices when weather prohibits us from playing on our game fields." said Fisher.
The recreation facilities will be used not only by school district teams, but also by community recreational teams. 



Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Turf and the environment

A few people have attacked the plan to turf a field in Mt. Lebanon by suggesting it is bad for the environment. Please take a minute to read these independent studies and get the rest of the story: http://www.fieldturf.com/environmental-downloads/ Interestingly, several people have pointed to studies by professors at the University of Arkansas, Michigan Stae and Missouri to suggest that artificial yturf is a bad alternative. However, each of those institutions has at least one turfed field, and most have up to three turfed facilities.

Update. Sorry for the delay!!

Things are moving forward at a pretty crazy pace these days. We have received multiple visits from various turf companies who have evaluated the field spaces in Mt. Lebanon. Several of these companies have submitted detailed bids that will be very helpful as we move forward. In related news, Commissioners Brumfield and Fraasch presented their preliminary bond proposals on Monday night. Commissioner Brumfield proposed a $3.2 million bond that included turf at Middle/Wildcat. Commissioner Fraasch proposed a $7 million bond that did not include any turf project, but it did provide for updates at a variety of other facilities. I am optimistic that there is a suitable middle ground that can greatly improve our field space inventory. The YSA members are actively working on a proposal that may be submitted to the Commissioners as early as this month. They have met with the Commissioners on several occasions to keep everyone up to speed. It is very exciting indeed, and there is more good news ahead.